More than a year after a breeder was formally warned against the maiming of animals, the National Council of SPCAs (NSPCA) welcomes the successful conviction of Carlene Coetzee for the illegal maiming of animals in contravention of the Animals Protection Act (APA) 71 of 1962. This conviction sets an important precedent, affirming that the physical alteration of animals for cosmetic or aesthetic purposes is unlawful and unacceptable.
In October 2023, Coetzee was issued with a warning regarding the maiming of animals at a dog show, after admitting to using rubber bands to remove the tails of puppies in her care. The removal of an animal’s tail, commonly referred to as tail docking, is illegal under the APA unless performed for legitimate veterinary or therapeutic reasons to improve the animal’s welfare and comfort.
In January 2024, following information received that Coetzee had once again illegally maimed Boerboel puppies, the NSPCA’s Special Projects Unit obtained a warrant to enter her property. Upon execution of the warrant, Inspector Govender and the NSPCA’s Veterinary Consultant, Dr Bryce Marock, were initially obstructed from entering the premises in an apparent attempt to delay the inspection.
Access was eventually gained, and during the subsequent search of the property, seven Boerboel puppies were discovered hidden in a wheelbarrow inside a garage. All seven puppies were found to have maimed tails.
After almost two years of pursuing this case, the NSPCA has secured a successful conviction against Coetzee for the illegal maiming of animals for cosmetic purposes. Coetzee was sentenced to a fine of R20,000 (twenty thousand rand) or, failing payment, ten (10) months’ imprisonment, half of which is suspended for a period of five (5) years on condition that she does not re-offend.
Tail docking is a traumatic and painful procedure, often performed without anaesthesia. When carried out incorrectly, or for reasons other than legitimate veterinary treatment, it can result in severe and long-lasting complications, including infections, difficulties with defecation and urination, and nerve damage. It also limits a dog’s ability to communicate and express natural behaviours.
Maiming cases are increasing at an alarming rate. The NSPCA believes this conviction serves a strong message to those who believe that tail maiming is necessary to serve “breed standards” or comply with the human notion of what a dog should look like.
If you are as passionate about animals and their well-being as we are, consider supporting our causes by donating.
Latest News Posts
Will You Be the One Who Takes Action?
Most people will scroll past this. But will you be the one who stands up for animals?
Animal welfare isn’t always in the spotlight, but it changes lives – for every neglected, abused, or suffering animal we help. Our teams work tirelessly, often behind the scenes, ensuring animals across South Africa are protected.
This work is relentless. The challenges are immense. But with more hands, hearts, and resources, we can do even more.
The equation is simple: the more supporters we have, the greater our reach, the stronger our impact.
Be part of the change. Become an NSPCA Project Partner today. From just R50 per month, you can help ensure that no animal suffers in silence.
